Component Description
The objective of the dietary interview component is to obtain detailed dietary intake information from the NHANES examined sample. All examinees are eligible for this component. The dietary intake data are used to estimate total intake of energy, nutrients, and non-nutrient food components from foods and beverages that were consumed during the 24-hour period prior to the interview (midnight to midnight). Following the dietary recall, a short "post-recall" questionnaire is administered; respondents estimate their intake of plain water during the previous 24-hour time period, and frequency of fish and shellfish consumption during the past 30 days. Two data files were produced from the dietary interview dataset: the Total Nutrient Intakes File (DRXTOT) that consists of total nutrient intakes, intake of plain water, and frequency of fish and shellfish data; and the Individual Foods File (DRXIFF) that includes detailed information about the individual foods reported by respondents. Nutrient intakes reported in these files do not include those obtained from dietary supplements, medications or plain drinking water.
Protocol and Procedure
Data Collection Methods
The NHANES computer-assisted dietary interview (CADI) system is an automated data collection form that was developed using Power BuilderTM; several databases (i.e., Quick List food list, brand name food list, and food amount unit list) are linked to this system. Food probes that were used in previous NHANES and USDA surveys became part of the built-in features of the system, developed using RoboHelpTM. The CADI provides a standardized interview format to collect NHANES dietary interview data.
The interviewers follow the scripts provided in the system screens to explain the dietary interview component to the respondents. The CADI screens include data entry screens, food probe information screens, and a post-recall questionnaire. The interviewers also record administrative information about the interview such as the main respondent and language of the interview, and reliability and completeness of the data.
The CADI interface includes the following screen features and data collection components:
- Online data entry screens
- Instructions for recording information about foods such as:
- brand names (selected food groups)
- food preparation methods: use of fat and salt in preparation, cooking methods, type of liquid added in recipe foods (selected food groups)
- Food amount options: food group-specific guidelines were listed for the interviewers so they would know how to probe for food amounts and record amount information
- Post-recall questionnaire
A “multiple pass” 24-hour dietary interview format was used to collect detailed information about all foods and beverages. The interview passes included the following:
- Quick List: Respondent was asked to recall all foods and beverages consumed in a 24-hour period the day before the interview without interrupting.
- Time, Occasion and Place: Respondent was asked to report the time and place each food was eaten and what they would call the eating occasion for the food. Afterwards, a list of frequently forgotten foods was shown to probe the respondent for any forgotten foods or drinks.
- Food Details: Specific food probes were used to collect detailed information for each food reported. This includes a complete description of each food and the amount eaten.
- Final Review: The reported foods were reviewed with the respondent in chronological order. Any additional foods remembered during the process were added to the record as well as modifications for reported foods.
The Post-Dietary Recall Questionnaire was administered after the 24-hour recall.
Detailed descriptions of the dietary interview methods are provided in the NHANES Dietary Interviewer’s Training Manual, available at: https://wwwn.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/continuousnhanes/default.aspx?BeginYear=1999.
Examination Protocol
All examinees are eligible for the dietary interview component. Proxy respondents were permitted for survey participants less than six years of age. Assisted interviews were completed with survey participants 6-11 years of age.
The primary interview mode for the NHANES 1999-2000 dietary recall component is the in-person interview mode. Interviews were conducted in a private setting in the NHANES Mobile Examination Centers (MECs). A methodological study, the Dietary Interview Mode Evaluation Study (DIMES) was conducted on a subsample of primary sampling units (PSUs) in both 1999 and 2000. The purpose of the DIMES was to test the operational feasibility of the telephone interview mode within the NHANES setting. For dietary interviews conducted in the DIMES PSUs, half were completed in-person and half were completed by telephone.
According to the NHANES sampling procedure, each participant was randomly assigned to either a morning exam session or an afternoon/evening exam session for his/her MEC visit. During the DIMES, examinees randomly assigned to the morning session completed the dietary interview in-person in the MEC. Those persons randomly assigned to an afternoon or evening MEC examination session were asked to schedule an appointment for a telephone dietary interview; a small percentage of afternoon and evening sample examinees completed their interviews in-person due to lack of telephone or personal scheduling problems. Telephone dietary interviews were conducted 4-10 days after the MEC health examination.
Dietary interviews were conducted in English and Spanish. Translators were used to conduct interviews in other languages.
Survey Staff
Trained, bilingual dietary interviewers collected all dietary interview data. Dietary interviewers were required to have a B.S. Degree in Food and Nutrition or Home Economics (with at least 10 credit hours in food and nutrition). All interviewers completed an intensive 2-week training course; formal training was followed by a week of supervised, practice interviewing.
Data Collection Forms
Please refer to the Dietary Interviewer’s Training Manual, available at: https://wwwn.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/continuousnhanes/default.aspx?BeginYear=1999. The Manual includes pictures of the CADI system screens, measurement guides, and charts used to collect dietary information. All data were collected and transmitted via automated systems; no printed forms were used.
Quality Assurance & Quality Control
The interviewers were required to review and edit all of their interviews. Written guidelines for completing the required procedures were developed for all survey staff. These procedures were reinforced during reviews of taped interviews and in-person observations, staff retraining, memos to the field, and informal e-mail correspondence.
The initial quality control consisted of:
- Reviews of data transmittal sheets to verify receipt of data files;
- Reviews of audio taped interviews for approximately 5% of each interviewer’s work;
- Reviews of completeness of the recalls: recalls were checked for missing information, inconsistent reports, and unclear notes; written notification and feedback were provided to the interviewers;
- 10% of the coders’ work was double-coded and adjudicated if necessary to ensure quality and completeness;
- Staff retraining for interviewers and coders was conducted as needed; annual retraining sessions are held with all MEC staff.
Data Processing and Editing
Interview data files were sent back to the home office electronically. The interview files were imported into the University of Texas Food Intake Analysis System (FIAS) for coding. FIAS version 3.99 with the USDA 1994-98 Survey Nutrient Database was used to code and report the NHANES 1999-2000 data.
After the initial coding, data files were transmitted for final processing. The final data processing consisting of:
- Modifying food records specified as "no salt added".
NCHS applied modified sodium values to foods when respondents specified that they did not use salt in preparation. An USDA Technical Support Recipe Data File developed for use with CSFII 1994-96 data was used to assign sodium values to foods reported as prepared without salt. (Note: No attempt was made to quantify salt added at the table.)
- Assigning USDA food codes to foods with modified recipes.
During the initial coding process, Westat coders assigned a 6-digit modified recipe food code and food description to modified recipe foods. An example of a modified recipe is an egg scrambled in olive oil instead of regular oil. The modified recipe code documents the actual recipe. Nutrients assigned to modified recipe foods reflect the recipe modification. The modified recipe codes were linked to a USDA food code that best characterized the food. All foods reported in the current NHANES are released with an 8-digit USDA food code as a means of providing a basic description of the food.
- Assigning USDA food codes to foods that are not in the USDA database.
During the initial coding process, Westat coders assigned a 7-digit food code and food description to foods that are not in the USDA database. Coding decisions were made in consultation with NCHS to assign nutrient values to the foods. Resources such as manufacturer information and University of Minnesota Nutrition Coordinating Center (NCC) nutrient composition database are used in making these decisions. An 8-digit USDA food code was assigned to the food to describe the basic characteristics of the food for reporting purposes.
- Computing total plain water and total home tap water intakes.
- Tabulating shellfish and fish frequency questionnaire data.
Data on total nutrient intakes, intake of plain water during the previous 24-hours, and frequency of fish and shellfish consumption during the past 30 days comprise the present file, titled "Total Nutrient Intakes File". The nutrient intakes reported in this file include nutrients from foods and beverages reported in the 24-hour dietary recall. The nutrient intakes do not include nutrients obtained from other sources (i.e., dietary supplements, antacids, medications, plain drinking water, and salt and seasonings added to foods at the table). Detailed information about the individual foods reported by respondents during the dietary interview is contained in a separate NHANES 1999-2000 Dietary Data File titled "Individual Foods File".
Analytic Notes
As was mentioned previously, two interview modes (in-person and telephone) were used to collect NHANES 1999-2000 dietary interview data. The variable DRDAINMD denotes the interview mode that originally assigned to the case while variable DRDINTMD indicates the actual mode by which the interview was administered. Analysis of dietary data should include investigation of the potential effect of interview mode on the estimates of interest. Data users who are interested in linking dietary data with data from other exam components such as blood biochemical data should be cognizant of the time lapse between the collections of phone-administered dietary interview (DRDINTMD=2) and other data of interest. Telephone dietary interviews were conducted 4-10 days after the NHANES health examination.
Special Notes on Using the Dataset
The Total Nutrient Intakes File provides a summary record of total nutrient intake for individuals as well as detailed information about the characteristics of the dietary interview. Summary information is reported for each survey participant. There is one record per survey participant in the file.
A status code (DRDDRSTS) is used in the current NHANES dietary interview component to indicate the quality and completeness of response to the dietary recall section. The dietary recall section status is coded as follows:
- Reliable and met the minimum criteria
The recall record was verified as reliable and met the following minimum criteria for the overall quality and completeness of the reported dietary information:
- Less than 25% foods with missing descriptive information (e.g., caffeinated or decaffeinated, preparation methods, or brand names);
- Less than 15% foods with missing amounts; and
- Any meal reported must have at least one known food. For example, if a respondent reported having a lunch but could not remember any foods from that lunch, the recall did not meet the criterion.
- Reliable but did not meet the minimum criteria
The dietary recall record was verified as reliable but did not meet the minimum criteria as stated in code 1.
- Not reliable
The dietary recall information provided by the respondent was determined to be unreliable. No data on total nutrient intake or individual food consumption was provided in the dataset for unreliable cases.
- Breast-fed infant or child
The foods reported during the dietary recall interview included human milk. Few respondents could quantify the human milk intake for their breast-fed infants/children. For those whose human milk intakes could not be quantified, no total nutrient intakes were derived. The foods consumed by nursing infants and children are reported in the Individual Foods File.
- Not Done
The dietary recall section of the interview did not take place due to various reasons (e.g. came late/left early, refusal, illness, emergency, or equipment failure).
In addition to the status codes described above, the variable DRQ300 indicates the nature of the reported dietary recall information from a different perspective. It denotes the respondent’s assessment of the overall intake for the recall day as to whether the amount of food consumed was a usual amount, more than usual, or less than usual.
A separate status code (DRASCST2) is included to indicate the nature of response for the post-recall questionnaire section. The section is coded as “complete” when an interview was attempted and finished for the section. A “partial” code indicates that the interview was interrupted due to various reasons (e.g. refusal, illness, emergency, or equipment failure), while a “not done” code indicates the interview of the section did not begin due to various reasons (e.g. came late/left early, refusal, illness, emergency, or equipment failure). Information encoded in this status variable is used to assess the section response and non-response rates.
Sample weights for dietary intake data: The NHANES participants were selected on the basis of a national probability design. In order to increase the number of participants for specific demographic groups, a multi-stage, unequal probability of selection design was implemented. The NHANES oversamples blacks, Mexican Americans, low income whites, adolescents 12-19 years, and persons 60 years and older. Sample weights are constructed that encompass the unequal probabilities of selection, as well as adjustments for non-participation by selected sample persons. In order to produce national, representative estimates, the appropriate sample weights must be used.
For the 1999-2000 NHANES, there were 12,160 persons selected; of these 9,282 were considered respondents to the MEC examination and data collection. However, only 8,730 of the MEC respondents provided complete dietary intakes.
Most analyses of NHANES data use data collected in the MEC and the variable WTMEC2YR should be used for the sample weights. However, for the dietary data, different sample weights are recommended for analysis. Although attempts are made to schedule MEC exams uniformly throughout the week, proportionally more exams occur on weekend days than on weekdays. Because food intake can vary by day of week, use of the MEC weights would disproportionately represent intakes on weekends.
A set of weights WTDRD1 is provided that should be used when an analysis uses the NHANES 1999-2000 dietary recall data (either alone or when nutrient data are used in conjunction with MEC data). The set of weights WTDRD1 is applicable to the 8,730 respondents with dietary data. The weights WTDRD1 were constructed by taking the MEC sample weights (WTMEC2YR) and further adjusting for (a) the additional non-response and (b) the differential allocation by day of the week for the dietary intake data collection. These weights are more variable than the MEC weights, and the sample size is smaller, so estimated standard errors using dietary data and dietary weights are larger than standard errors for similar estimates based on MEC weights. In addition, a set of four-year dietary weight (WTDR4YR) is also provided that should be used for the combined analyses of NHANES 1999-2000 and NHANES 2001-2002 data.
Note that all sample weights are person-level weights and each set of weights should add to the same population control total as the MEC weights (WTMEC2YR). In addition, the MEC weights (WTMEC2YR) are appropriate for use in the analysis of the fish and shellfish consumption data (i.e., variables DRQ340, DRD350A-K, DRQ350AQ-JQ, DRQ360, DRD370A-V, and DRQ370AQ-UQ) located in the Total Nutrient Intake File (DRXTOT), if no other dietary data are included in the analysis. Additional explanation of sample weights and appropriate uses are included in the NHANES Analytic Guidelines (https://wwwn.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/analyticguidelines.aspx). Please also refer to the on-line NHANES Tutorial (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/tutorials/) for further details on other analytic issues.