Skip directly to site content Skip directly to page options

Inspection Detail Report

  Advanced Search |  Ship Scored 100 |  Green Sheet  |  CDC Home |  VSP Home
 
Cruise Ship: Club Med 2 Cruise Line: Club Med Marine Inspection Date: 11/14/2011 Inspection Score: 92
This cruise ship inspection report lists deficiencies found during the inspection. Additional information corresponding to each item number is available in the latest edition of the VSP Environmental Public Health Standards.

View/Print Summary Report  |  View/Print Corrective Action Statement
Item No.: 16
Site: Galley-Magellan Pantry
Violation: The middle left upright refrigerator was not holding at a uniform temperature distribution at or below 41°F. Food products on the bottom shelves and toward the door were measured at temperatures ranging from 44-50°F. These food products included individual yogurt containers (approximately 15), and assorted soft cheeses (2), these products were discarded. The food products on the middle and top shelves of the refrigerator as well as the products toward the back were measured at or below the required 41°F. A work order was placed to fix the issue.
Recommendation: Except during preparation, cooking, or cooling, or when time is used as the public health control, maintain potentially hazardous foods at 57°C (135°F) or above, except that roasts may be held at a temperature of 54°C (130°F); or 5°C (41°F) or less.
Item No.: 20
Site: Galley-Magellan Pantry
Violation: The middle left upright refrigerator was not holding at a uniform temperature distribution at or below 41°F. Food products on the bottom shelves and toward the door were measured at temperatures ranging from 44-50°F. These food products included individual yogurt containers (approximately 15), and assorted soft cheeses (2), these products were discarded. The food products on the middle and top shelves of the refrigerator as well as the products toward the back were measured at or below the required 41°F. A work order was placed to fix the issue.
Recommendation: Ensure equipment for cooling and heating food, and holding cold and hot food, is sufficient in number and capacity to maintain potentially hazardous food temperatures. Food contact equipment must be maintained in good repair and proper adjustment: (1) Equipment must be maintained in a state of repair and condition that meets the materials, design, construction, and operating specifications of these guidelines.
Item No.: 33
Site: Food Service General-Decks
Violation: The decks throughout the galleys and warewash areas had recessed and missing deck grout. The painted decks inside technical spaces were rough.
Recommendation: Ensure decks in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are maintained in good repair.
Item No.: 16
Site: Food Service General-Time Control Plan
Violation: The current time control plans at each food outlet did not specify the hot and cold holding units on time control, nor were the units physically labeled as such. [New requirement 2011 VSP Operations Manual]
Recommendation: Maintain a written time control plan(s) that ensures compliance with these guidelines on the vessel and make it available for review during inspections. Post a time control plan at each outlet where time control is used. Ensure plan(s): (1) Includes set-up and discard times for each outlet. (2) List refrigeration and hot holding units (compartments and cabinets) on time control (the physical units must also be labeled as such). (3) Describe or show the flow of potentially hazardous food from when last in temperature control to placement in time control and discard.
Item No.: 36
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea
Violation: The lighting at the clean storage pantries on both the port and starboard side could not be raised to 220 lux.
Recommendation: Ensure the light intensity is at least 220 lux (20 foot candles) at a distance of 75 centimeters (30 inches) above the deck in food preparation areas, utensil storage, pantries, toilet rooms, and consumer self-service areas.
Item No.: 19
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea
Violation: A container of cooking oil was stored on the deck inside the technical compartment below the coffee machine at the port side clean storage pantry.
Recommendation: Protect food from contamination by storing the food: (1) Covered or otherwise protected; (2) In a clean, dry location; (3) Where it is not exposed to splash, dust, or other contamination; and (4) At least 15 centimeters (6 inches) above the deck.
Item No.: 16
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea
Violation: There was no consumer advisory posted at the self-service egg cooking station. [New requirement 2011 VSP Operations Manual]
Recommendation: If an animal food such as beef, eggs, fish, lamb, milk, pork, poultry, or shellfish that is raw, undercooked, or not otherwise processed to eliminate pathogens is offered in a ready-to-eat form or as a raw ingredient in another ready-to-eat food, ensure the consumer is informed by way of disclosure using menu advisories, placards, or other easily visible written means of the significantly increased risk to certain especially vulnerable consumers eating such foods in raw or undercooked form.
Item No.: 21
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea Forward/Port Beverage Station
Violation: There were holes in the bottom of the technical compartment immediately below the ice dispenser. The holes prevented the bottom of the compartment from being smooth and easily cleanable and also created a void space between the two bottom panels of the technical compartment.
Recommendation: Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment that are exposed to splash, spillage, or other food soiling or that require frequent cleaning are constructed of a corrosion-resistant, nonabsorbent, and smooth material.
Item No.: 28
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea Starboard
Violation: Two hot plates were stored on the deck inside a soiled technical compartment immediately below the cold service line next to the handwash station.
Recommendation: Store cleaned equipment and utensils, laundered linens, and single-service and single-use articles: (1) in a clean, dry location; (2) in a location where they are not exposed to splash, dust, or other contamination; (3) at least 150 millimeters (6 inches) above the deck.
Item No.: 27
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea Starboard
Violation: The technical compartment immediately below the cold service line next to the handwash station was soiled with food debris.
Recommendation: Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment are kept free of an accumulation of dust, dirt, food residue, and other debris.
Item No.: 34
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea Starboard
Violation: The plumbing at the handwash station was in poor repair as water spilled onto the deck when the faucet was engaged. This was corrected.
Recommendation: Ensure a plumbing system in a food area is maintained in good repair.
Item No.: 39
Site: Buffet-Mediterranea Starboard
Violation: A live fruit fly was observed flying above the cold self-service line while in operation.
Recommendation: Effectively control the presence of insects, rodents, and other pests to minimize their presence in the food storage, preparation, and service areas and warewashing and utensil storage areas aboard a vessel.
Item No.: 22
Site: Galley-Mediterranea Hot Pantry
Violation: Three soiled cooking pans were stored on the deck next to the oven.
Recommendation: Ensure drainboards, utensils, racks, or tables large enough to accommodate all soiled items that may accumulate during hours of operation are provided for necessary utensil holding before cleaning.
Item No.: 21
Site: Galley-Mediterranea Hot Pantry
Violation: The doors on the equipment storage cabinet below the prep table adjacent to the deep fryer were not closing properly allowing soiled water used to clean the prep table leak inside.
Recommendation: Design and construct nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment to be durable and to retain their characteristic qualities under normal use conditions.
Item No.: 26
Site: Galley-Mediterranea Hot Pantry
Violation: Previously cleaned and sanitized grey buffet serving containers stored inside the storage cabinet below the prep table next to the deep fryer were holding dirty water that leaked through the cabinet doors when cleaning the prep table. More than 8 storage containers were kept in the cabinet that were soiled in this manner.
Recommendation: Ensure food contact surfaces of equipment and utensils are clean to sight and touch. Store cleaned equipment and utensils: (1) in a clean, dry location; (2) in a location where they are not exposed to splash, dust, or other contamination; (3) at least 150 millimeters (6 inches) above the deck.
Item No.: 28
Site: Galley-Mediterranea Hot Pantry
Violation: Previously cleaned and sanitized grey buffet serving containers stored inside the storage cabinet below the prep table next to the deep fryer were holding dirty water that leaked through the cabinet doors when cleaning the prep table. More than 8 storage containers were kept in the cabinet that were soiled in this manner.
Recommendation: Ensure food contact surfaces of equipment and utensils are clean to sight and touch. Store cleaned equipment and utensils: (1) in a clean, dry location; (2) in a location where they are not exposed to splash, dust, or other contamination; (3) at least 150 millimeters (6 inches) above the deck.
Item No.: 26
Site: Galley-Mediterranea Warewashing
Violation: More than 8 previously cleaned and sanitized small brown serving containers used for serving rice pudding were observed soiled with food residue.
Recommendation: Ensure food contact surfaces of equipment and utensils are clean to sight and touch.
Item No.: 39
Site: Galley-Mediterranea Hot Pantry
Violation: One live fruit fly was observed in this area. The area was not in use at the time.
Recommendation: Effectively control the presence of insects, rodents, and other pests to minimize their presence in the food storage, preparation, and service areas and warewashing and utensil storage areas aboard a vessel.
Item No.: 26
Site: Galley-Hot Galley
Violation: Approximately eight previously cleaned and sanitized utensils that were not in use were stored on a soiled baking tray. The utensils and tray were sent to be cleaned and sanitized.
Recommendation: Ensure food contact surfaces of equipment and utensils are clean to sight and touch. Store cleaned utensils in a clean, dry location.
Item No.: 17
Site: Galley-Cooling Log
Violation: Two food items: cooked pasta and bonognase sauce, were not listed in the cooling log under the proper date. These food items were marked with the date they were to be served rather than the date they were cooked and cooled.
Recommendation: Ensure logs documenting cooling of potentially hazardous foods prepared from ingredients at ambient temperatures, with the start time to the time when 5°C (41 °F) is reached are also maintained for a period of 30 days, beginning with the day of preparation.
Item No.: 20
Site: Food Service General-Food Probe Thermometers
Violation: There were no food probe temperature measuring devices available, only surface temperature infrared guns.
Recommendation: Ensure food temperature-measuring devices are provided and readily accessible for use in ensuring attainment and maintenance of food temperatures. Use tip-sensitive temperature-measuring devices, such as a thermocouple or thermistor, for measuring thin food products.
Item No.: 13
Site: Food Service General-Temperature Monitoring
Violation: There were no food probe temperature measuring devices available, only surface temperature infrared guns. When asked how cooking temperatures are taken to ensure the food products reach the required minimum internal temperature, the inspector was informed by using the infrared thermometers. It was also explained that the cooling temperatures are taken by the infrared thermometers and recorded in the cooling logs.
Recommendation: Because of the risks for foodborne illness inherent to the food operation, ensure the supervisor or person in charge of food operations on the vessel demonstrates to VSP - during inspections and on request - knowledge of foodborne disease prevention, application of the Hazard Analysis Critical Point principles, and the food-safety guidelines in this manual. Ensure that the person in charge demonstrates this knowledge: (1) By compliance with these guidelines; (2) Explaining the significance of the relation between maintaining the time and temperature of potentially hazardous food and the prevention of foodborne illness; (3) Explaining the relation between food safety and providing equipment that is sufficient in number and capacity as well as properly designed, constructed, located, installed, operated, maintained, and cleaned.
Item No.: 17
Site: Food Service General-Temperature Monitoring
Violation: There were no food probe temperature measuring devices available, only surface temperature infrared guns. When asked how cooking temperatures are taken to ensure the food products reach the required minimum internal temperature, the inspector was informed with the infrared thermometers. It was also explained that the cooling temperatures are taken by the infrared thermometers and recorded in the cooling logs.
Recommendation: Internal temperatures must be taken using food probe thermometers to ensure proper temperatures are achieved when cooking and cooling.
Item No.: 24
Site: Galley-Bakery
Violation: There was a bucket of sanitizing solution that measured more than 200 ppm chlorine.
Recommendation: Ensure sanitizing solutions are used with the following concentrations: (1) A chlorine solution with a concentration between 50 mg/L (ppm) and 200 mg/L (ppm).
Item No.: 16
Site: Galley-Bakery Upright Refigerator #2
Violation: The upright refrigerator was holding above 41°F. Containers of whipping cream were measured at temperatures between 45-47°F and were discarded. Pastries with a cream filling had temperatures that ranged from 42-45°F. This product was placed in the blast freezer since they were just prepared one hour prior.
Recommendation: Except during preparation, cooking, or cooling, or when time is used as the public health control, maintain potentially hazardous foods at 57°C (135°F) or above, except that roasts may be held at a temperature of 54°C (130°F); or 5°C (41°F) or less.
Item No.: 34
Site: Buffet-
Violation: There was a water leak coming from the plumbing inside the technical compartment underneath the baine marie.
Recommendation: Ensure a plumbing system in a food area is maintained in good repair.
Item No.: 33
Site: Dining Room-Magellan
Violation: There was missing grout at the deck and coving juncture at the center waiting station.
Recommendation: Ensure decks in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are maintained in good repair.
Item No.: 20
Site: Food Service General-Upright Refrigeration Units
Violation: An upright refrigeration unit in both the bakery and in the Magellan Galley were observed holding at temperatures ranging from 43-47°F. PHF was being held in each of these units.
Recommendation: Ensure equipment for cooling and heating food, and holding cold and hot food, is sufficient in number and capacity to maintain potentially hazardous food temperatures.
Item No.: 02
Site: Medical-AGE Log
Violation: The ship was not using the new acute gastroenteritis surveillance log provided in the VSP Operations Manual 2011. [New requirement 2011 VSP Operations Manual]
Recommendation: Ensure the AGE surveillance log entry for each passenger or crew member contain the following information in separate columns: (1) Date of the first medical visit or report to staff of illness; (2) time of the first medical visit or report to staff of illness; (3) case identification number; (4) person's name; (5) person's age; (6) person's sex; (7) designation as passenger or crew member; (8) crew member position or job on the vessel, if applicable; (9) cabin number; (10) meal seating information; (11) date of illness onset; (12) time of illness onset; (13) illness symptoms, including the presence or absence of the following selected signs and symptoms, with a separate column for each of the following: (a) number of episodes of diarrhea in a 24-hour period; (b) number of episodes of vomiting in a 24-hour period; (c) bloody stools; (d) recorded temperature; (e) abdominal cramps; (f) headaches; (g) muscle aches; (14) entry (yes/no) for whether this was a reportable case; (15) entry (yes/no) for antidiarrheal medications sold or dispensed by designated medical staff; (16) presence of underlying medical conditions that may affect interpretation of AGE. Ensure the AGE surveillance log contains the above information in the exact order and is entered in the template in Annex 13.2.2. Ensure that the log data is exported in the exact order as in the example template in Annex 13.2.2 with analyzable formats such as Excel or Access. Ensure that any additional data fields are entered only outside of the form margins when exported to VSP.
Item No.: 02
Site: Medical-Clinical Specimen Collection
Violation: The clinical specimen collection containers for bacterial analysis expired in April 2011. New containers have been ordered.
Recommendation: Ensure the medical staff maintains a supply of at least 10 non expired clinical specimen collection containers for both viral and bacterial agents (10 for each), as well as a shipping container that meets the latest shipping requirements of the International Air Transport Association (IATA) and U.S. Department of Transportation for Biological Substances, Category B designated shipments (or higher).
Item No.: 41
Site: Housekeeping-Outbreak Prevention and Response Plan (OPRP)
Violation: The written OPRP was missing details such as the contact time for chlorine disinfection of surfaces, ill cabin disinfectant was not named, but the concentration was given (300-500 ppm) and no contact time was described. In the first section, surface cleaning was specified on 20 minute intervals, and in section 3 for public area sanitizing a time of every 15 minutes was given.
Recommendation: Ensure each vessel has a written OPRP that details standard procedures and policies to specifically address AGE onboard. Include the following in the written OPRP: (1) Disinfectant products or systems used, including the surfaces or items the disinfectants will be applied to, concentrations, and required contact times. Ensure the disinfectant products or systems are effective against human norovirus or an acceptable surrogate (e.g., caliciviruses).
Item No.: 41
Site: Housekeeping-Outbreak Prevention and Response Plan (OPRP)
Violation: In section 3 of the OPRP soft furnishings were said to be sprayed with a sanitizing agent, but no name was given and no concentration or contact time was provided. Fogging of ill person cabins was described, but again the product was not named and there was no concentration. There was no written personal protection instructions for either persons carrying out the various procedures and using chemicals or for the passengers who would be potentially exposed. Lastly, there was no procedure in the OPRP to notify the embarking passengers following an outbreak onboard.
Recommendation: Ensure each vessel has a written OPRP that details standard procedures and policies to specifically address AGE onboard. Include the following in the written OPRP: (1) Disinfectant products or systems used, including the surfaces or items the disinfectants will be applied to, concentrations, and required contact times. Ensure the disinfectant products or systems are effective against human norovirus or an acceptable surrogate (e.g., caliciviruses); (2) Procedures for informing passengers and crew members of the outbreak. Ensure this section also includes procedures for notification of passengers embarking the vessel following an outbreak voyage or segment of a voyage; (3) Procedures to protect the passengers and crew from exposure to disinfectants, if not already included in the vessel's safety management system. Ensure this protection includes: (a) Material safety data sheets (MSDSs); (b) Personal protective equipment for crew; (c) Health and safety procedures to minimize respiratory and dermal exposures to both passengers and crew.
Item No.: 41
Site: Housekeeping-Crew and Passenger Public Toilets
Violation: There were no signs in either the crew or public toilets advising users to wash their hands. Additionally, there was no signs in either the crew or passenger public toilets advising users to use the sanitizing wipes to open the exit door. The ship used electric hand dryers and had no paper towels or tissues in the toilet rooms.
Recommendation: Provide the passenger and crew public toilets with a handwashing station that includes: (1) Hot and cold running water; (2) Soap; (3) A method to dry hands; (4) A sign advising users to wash hands. Equip passenger and crew public toilet facilities so persons exiting the toilet room are not required to touch the door handle with bare hands. Where toilet stalls include handwashing facilities, ensure the bare-hands-free contact begins in the toilet stall. Ensure that toilet facilities with multiple exits, such as spa dressing rooms, have bare-hands-free contact at each exit.
Item No.: 40
Site: Integrated Pest Management-Records
Violation: Staff stated that active monitoring inspections were conducted as part of the passive monitoring check for traps, but there were no inspection times written in the log to ensure at least some of these were conducted at night.
Recommendation: Ensure the IPM plan, monitoring records, and other documentation are available for review during inspections.
Item No.: 40
Site: Integrated Pest Management-Records
Violation: The inspection records listed several areas of inspection, but did not included the garbage processing (collecting) room. Staff stated that this was inspected along with the garbage storage area, which in the logs was inspected weekly.
Recommendation: Ensure the IPM plan, monitoring records, and other documentation are available for review during inspections.
Item No.: 08
Site: Potable Water-Mineralizer
Violation: The backwash drain line for the mineralizers used in the production of potable water (reverse osmosis) was protected from backflow by way of an air-gap to the bilge, but it was not among the backflow prevention devices/methods listed for inspection.
Recommendation: Ensure the cross-connection control program includes at a minimum: a complete listing of cross-connections and the backflow prevention method or device for each, so there is a match to the plumbing system component and location. Include air gaps on the listing. Ensure a schedule for inspection frequency is set. Maintain a log documenting the inspection and maintenance in written or electronic form, and ensure it is available for review during inspections.
Item No.: 08
Site: Potable Water-Reverse Osmosis Plant
Violation: The permeate water pipes from the reverse osmosis plant to the chlorine injection point were striped blue for potable water, rather than blue/gray/blue as per ISO 14726. [New requirement 2011 VSP Operations Manual]
Recommendation: Stripe or paint potable water lines either in accordance with ISO 14726 (blue/green/blue) or blue only. Stripe or paint distillate and permeate lines directed to the potable water system in accordance with ISO 14726 (blue/gray/blue). Ensure no other lines have the above color designations. Stripe or paint these lines at 5 meters (15 feet) intervals and on each side of partitions, decks, and bulkheads, except where decor would be marred by such markings, including potable water supply lines in technical lockers.
Item No.: 08
Site: Potable Water-Potable Water Tanks
Violation: The electronic record for the coating of the potable water tanks 3 starboard and 1 port (both in September 2011) did not include a description of the paint used, no written documentation of the approval (by and independent testing organization) approving it for potable water use, or documentation that the manufacturer's recommendations were followed in the application of the paint, the drying, and the curing.
Recommendation: Ensure the interior coatings on potable water tanks are approved for potable water contact by a certification organization. Follow all manufacturers' recommendations for application, drying, and curing. For the tank coatings used, maintain the following onboard: (1) written documentation of approval from the certification organization (independent of the coating manufacturer); (2) manufacturers' recommendations for application, drying, and curing; and (3) written documentation that the manufacturers' recommendations have been followed for application, drying, and curing.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Forward and Aft Pools
Violation: The written procedure for the fecal and vomit accident procedure is a photo copy of the VSP Operations Manual 2011 sample plan in Annex 13.8. The title: sample Fecal /Vomit Accident Procedure has not been removed and the ship's fleet instruction 82.8.4 states only that the following is an example of a fecal accident procedure. It does not state that this specific procedure is to be followed.
Recommendation: The fleet instruction should be modified to specifically require the example procedure to be followed in the case of a fecal or vomit accident in the pools onboard.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Forward and Aft Pools
Violation: There was no automated free halogen residual and pH testing for either pool. No data logging, analyzer, or chart recording equipment was installed for monitoring halogen and pH levels in the pools, and no alarm for low and high levels was installed in either. [New requirement 2011 VSP Operations Manual]
Recommendation: Install automated systems for halogen-based disinfection and pH control dosing. Control the amounts injected by flow meters or free halogen and pH analyzers. Install chart recorders or electronic data loggers with security features that record pH and halogen measurements for each individual RWF. Ensure the sample line for the analyzer probe (monitoring) is either directly from the RWF or on the return line from each RWF and before the compensation tank. Install appropriate sample taps for analyzer calibration. In the event of equipment failure, measure free residual halogen and pH by a manual test kit at the RWF or return line at least hourly for whirlpool spas, spa pools, children's pools, and wading pools and every 4 hours for all other RWFs. Record manual readings on a chart or log, retain for at least 12 months, and ensure that they are available for review during inspections. Complete repairs on malfunctioning halogen analyzer-chart recorders within 30 days of equipment failure. Provide an audible alarm in a continuously occupied watch station to indicate low and high free halogen and pH readings in each RWF.
Item No.: 16
Site: Dining Room-Magellan Restaurant
Violation: There was no consumer advisory included in the menu and nothing pointing to the specific menu items which included animal-derived foods served in a raw, marinated, or undercooked form. [New requirement 2011 VSP Operations Manual]
Recommendation: If an animal food such as beef, eggs, fish, lamb, milk, pork, poultry, or shellfish that is raw, undercooked, or not otherwise processed to eliminate pathogens is offered in a ready-to-eat form or as a raw ingredient in another ready-to-eat food, ensure the consumer is informed by way of disclosure using menu advisories, placards, or other easily visible written means of the significantly increased risk to certain especially vulnerable consumers eating such foods in raw or undercooked form. Ensure the advisory is on a menu by using an asterisk at the animal-derived foods requiring disclosure and a footnote with a statement indicating that consuming raw or undercooked meats, seafood, shellfish, eggs, milk, or poultry may increase your risk for foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Item No.: 16
Site: Food Service General-All Food Areas
Violation: Staff labeled all ready-to-eat potentially hazardous foods in storage with the preparation date, rather than the discard date.
Recommendation: Ensure refrigerated, ready-to-eat, potentially hazardous food is discarded if not consumed within 7 calendar days from the date of preparation or opening.
Item No.: 26
Site: Bar-Venice Bar Pantry
Violation: The underside of the white plastic drain pan installed below the cuber panel in the Kold Draft ice machine was heavily soiled with black mold. Water was dripping from this moldy surface directly into the ice in the bin below. Additionally, the drain hose was detached from the bottom of the drain pan, so dirty water was draining directly from the pan into the ice in the bin below.
Recommendation: Ensure food only contacts surfaces of equipment and utensils that are cleaned and sanitized. Food contact equipment must be maintained in good repair and proper adjustment: (1) Equipment must be maintained in a state of repair and condition that meets the materials, design, construction, and operating specifications of these guidelines.
*Inspections scores of 85 or lower are NOT satisfactory
Vessel Sanitation Program