Skip directly to site content Skip directly to page options

Inspection Detail Report

  Advanced Search |  Ship Scored 100 |  Green Sheet  |  CDC Home |  VSP Home
 
Cruise Ship: Crystal Symphony Cruise Line: Crystal Cruises LTD Inspection Date: 01/20/2012 Inspection Score: 100
This cruise ship inspection report lists deficiencies found during the inspection. Additional information corresponding to each item number is available in the latest edition of the VSP Environmental Public Health Standards.

View/Print Summary Report  |  View/Print Corrective Action Statement
Item No.: 03
Site: Potable Water-Bunkering pH
Violation: In November and December 2011, there were several days where the pH of bunkered water was above 7.8 for the entire period. The pH was monitored correctly, but not adjusted to be 7.8 or below.
Recommendation: Continuously halogenate potable water to at least 2.0 mg/L (ppm) free residual halogen at the time of bunkering or production with an automatic halogenation device that is controlled by a flow meter and adjust the pH so it does not exceed 7.8. Ensure the amount of halogen injected during bunkering or production is controlled by a flow meter or a free halogen analyzer.
Item No.: 08
Site: Potable Water-Distillate Lines
Violation: The distillate lines between the evaporator and the production halogenation station were not striped in accordance with ISO 14726 (blue/gray/blue).
Recommendation: Stripe or paint distillate and permeate lines directed to the potable water system in accordance with ISO 14726 (blue/gray/blue). Ensure no other lines have the above color designations. Stripe or paint these lines at 5 meters (15 feet) intervals and on each side of partitions, decks, and bulkheads, except where decor would be marred by such markings, including potable water supply lines in technical lockers.
Item No.: 06
Site: Potable Water-Secondary Standards
Violation: There were no secondary standards to verify the operation of the test kit used to calibrate the far point analyzer chart recorder.
Recommendation: Where available, maintain appropriate secondary standards onboard for electronic test kits to verify test kit operation.
Item No.: 08
Site: Potable Water-Tank Coatings
Violation: There was no written documentation of the approval of the potable water tank coatings from the certification organization.
Recommendation: Ensure the interior coatings on potable water tanks are approved for potable water contact by a certification organization.For the tank coatings used, maintain the following onboard: (1) written documentation of approval from the certification organization (independent of the coating manufacturer);
Item No.: 08
Site: Potable Water-Tank Maintenance Records
Violation: The written documentation for tank maintenance did not include the drying and curing of the tank coating. The AMOS task instructions indicated that SIGMA guidelines will be followed.
Recommendation: Follow all manufacturers' recommendations for application, drying, and curing. For the tank coatings used, maintain the following onboard: (3) written documentation that the manufacturers' recommendations have been followed for application, drying, and curing.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Fecal Accident Plan
Violation: The fecal accident plan did not include vomit accidents and did not provide a high enough halogenation and contact time for disinfection following a loose stool accident.
Recommendation: Ensure a fecal and vomit accident response procedure that meets or exceeds the procedure provided in Annex 13.8 is available for review during inspections.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Filter Housings and Hair Stainers
Violation: There was no documentation of cleaning, rinsing and disinfection of the cartridge filter housings or for the hair strainers and hair strainer housings.
Recommendation: Clean, rinse, and disinfect the filter housing before the new filter media is placed in it. Ensure disinfection is accomplished with an appropriate halogen-based disinfectant. At a minimum, use a 50-ppm solution for 1 minute, or equivalent CT value. Maintain records on all inspection and cleaning procedures. Clean, rinse, and disinfect the hair and lint strainer and hair and lint strainer housing on all RWFs weekly. Ensure disinfection is accomplished with an appropriate halogen-based disinfectant. At a minimum, use a 50-ppm solution for 1 minute, or equivalent CT value. Maintain records on all inspection and cleaning procedures.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Secondary Standards
Violation: There were no secondary standards to verify the operation of the electronic test kits used to monitor halogen in the recreational water facilities.
Recommendation: Where available, ensure appropriate secondary standards are onboard for electronic test kits to verify test kit operation.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Turnover Rate and Bather Load
Violation: The turnover rates and bather load calculations were no available for the pool and whirlpool.
Recommendation: Design recirculation systems and equipment, including chemical control equipment, UV disinfection systems, filter, and pumps to maintain adequate water chemistry control while operating at the following minimum turnover rates: (1) swimming pool (VSP 2005 Construction Guidelines or earlier): 6 hours; (2) swimming pool (VSP 2011 Construction Guidelines or later): 4 hours; (3) children's pool: 0.5 hours; (4) wading pool: 1 hour; (5) whirlpool spa: 0.5 hours; (6) spa pool: 2 hours; (7) interactive RWF or activity pool less than 610 millimeters (24 inches) deep: 1 hour; (8) interactive RWF or activity pool greater than 610 millimeters (24 inches) deep: 2 hours; and (9) baby-only water facility: 0.5 hours. Ensure an RWF slide that is combined with a pool has a turnover rate that matches the rate for the pool. Maintain documentation on the maximum bather load for each RWF. Ensure the maximum bather load is based on the following factor: one person per five gallons (19 liters) per minute of recirculation flow.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Alkalinity
Violation: The alkalinity was not monitored for the recreational water facilities.
Recommendation: Monitor and adjust the RWF's flow rates, free and combined halogen levels, pH, total alkalinity, and clarity as recommended by the manufacturer and to maintain optimum public health protection and water chemistry.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Antientrapment Drain Covers
Violation: The whirlpool had suction fittings for the therapy jets with antientrapment drain covers, but there was no safety vacuum release system or automatic pump shut-off system installed on the suction lines.
Recommendation: For RWFs with suction fittings and a single blockable drain or multiple drains (less than 3 feet apart), provide an ASME A112.19.8 compliant antientrapment/antientanglement drain cover and a safety vacuum release system or automatic pump shut-off system.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Antientrapment Drain Covers
Violation: The documentation for the drain covers for the pool did not indicate that they complied with ASME A112.19.8-2007.
Recommendation: For RWFs with gravity drainage and a single blockable drain or multiple drains less than 3 feet apart, provide an ASME A112.19.8 compliant antientrapment/antientanglement drain cover and a gravity drainage system.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Safety Signs
Violation: The whirlpool safety sign did not include: do not use these facilities if you are experiencing diarrhea, vomiting, or fever; no children in diapers or who are not toilet trained; shower before entering the facility; bather load number; caution against use by persons with low blood pressure; or caution against use by pregnant women, elderly persons, and children.
Recommendation: Provide safety signs for all RWFs, except for baby-only water facilities. Ensure the signs, at a minimum, include the following words: (1) do not use these facilities if you are experiencing diarrhea, vomiting, or fever; (2) no children in diapers or who are not toilet trained; (3) shower before entering the facility; and (4) bather load #. In addition to the safety sign requirements in section 6.7.1.1.1, install a sign at each whirlpool spa and spa pool entrance listing precautions and risks associated with the use of these facilities. Include, at a minimum, cautions against use by the following: (1) individuals who are immunocompromised; (2) individuals on medication or who have underlying medical conditions such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, or high or low blood pressure; and (3) pregnant women, elderly persons, and children. Additionally, caution against exceeding 15 minutes of exposure.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Shock Halogenation
Violation: The whirlpool was shock halogenated every 3 days and not daily.
Recommendation: Increase the free residual halogen to at least 10.0 mg/L (ppm) and circulate for at least 1 hour every 24 hours. Test the free residual halogen both at the start and completion of shock halogenation. Superhalogenate the water in the entire RWF system to 10 ppm to include the whirlpool spa/spa pool tub, compensation tank, filter housing, and all associated piping before starting the 1-hour timing.
Item No.: 10
Site: Recreational Water Facilities-Analyzer-Chart Recorders
Violation: There were no halogen an pH analyzer-chart recorders installed on the pool or whirlpool.
Recommendation: Install chart recorders or electronic data loggers with security features that record pH and halogen measurements for each individual RWF. Ensure the sample line for the analyzer probe (monitoring) is either directly from the RWF or on the return line from each RWF and before the compensation tank. Install appropriate sample taps for analyzer calibration. In the event of equipment failure, measure free residual halogen and pH by a manual test kit at the RWF or return line at least hourly for whirlpool spas, spa pools, children's pools, and wading pools and every 4 hours for all other RWFs. Record manual readings on a chart or log, retain for at least 12 months, and ensure that they are available for review during inspections. Complete repairs on malfunctioning halogen analyzer-chart recorders within 30 days of equipment failure. Provide an audible alarm in a continuously occupied watch station to indicate low and high free halogen and pH readings in each RWF.
Item No.: 41
Site: Housekeeping-Public Toilets
Violation: There were no signs informing people to wash their hands or to use a tissue on the door handle when exiting the toilet room.
Recommendation: Provide the passenger and crew public toilets with a handwashing station that includes: (1) Hot and cold running water; (2) Soap; (3) A method to dry hands; (4) A sign advising users to wash hands. Post a sign advising users of toilet facilities to use hand towel, paper towel, or tissue to open the door unless the exit is hands free.
Item No.: 41
Site: Housekeeping-Outbreak Prevention and Response Plan (OPRP)
Violation: The OPRP did not provide measures to inform current passengers and crew during an outbreak or embarking passengers of an outbreak on the previous cruise. Also, the OPRP indicated that Virkon or Virox wipes would be used during an outbreak, but the vessel was using Relyon.
Recommendation: Ensure each vessel has a written OPRP that details standard procedures and policies to specifically address AGE onboard. Include the following in the written OPRP: (3) Disinfectant products or systems used, including the surfaces or items the disinfectants will be applied to, concentrations, and required contact times. Ensure the disinfectant products or systems are effective against human norovirus or an acceptable surrogate (e.g., caliciviruses); (4) Procedures for informing passengers and crew members of the outbreak. Ensure this section also includes procedures for notification of passengers embarking the vessel following an outbreak voyage or segment of a voyage;
Item No.: 10
Site: Housekeeping-Cabin Whilrpool Disinfection
Violation: For one time each month in October, November, and December, the time between disinfections of the cabin whirlpools was longer than 7 days (8-10 days).
Recommendation: Clean and disinfect private whirlpool spas located in individual passenger cabins, including associated recirculation systems, between occupancies or weekly, whichever is more frequent. Ensure disinfection is accomplished with an appropriate halogen-based disinfectant at 10 ppm for 60 minutes, or an equivalent CT value.
Item No.: 08
Site: Potable Water-Cabin 1007
Violation: There was no backflow prevention device for the shower hose. The hose was long enough to reach the deck in the shower stall. This was corrected during the inspection.
Recommendation: Use air gaps where feasible and where water under pressure is not required. Install backflow prevention devices when air gaps are impractical or when water under pressure is required.
Item No.: 42
Site: Children Area-Handwash Station
Violation: The handwashing station was more than 22 inches above the deck and there was no step stool.
Recommendation: Ensure handwashing sinks have a maximum height of 560 millimeters (22 inches) above the deck or a step stool.
Item No.: 01
Site: Medical-Acute Gastroenteritis (AGE) Reporting
Violation: On the 12/11 - 12/21/2011 cruise, the vessel reported 1 ill passenger but the AGE log indicated 3 ill passengers.
Recommendation: Ensure the master, medical staff, or other designated staff of a vessel destined for a U.S. port from a foreign port submits at least one standardized AGE report based on the number of reportable cases in the AGE log to VSP no less than 24 hours-but not more than 36 hours-before the vessel's expected arrival at the U.S. port.
Item No.: 02
Site: Medical-Acute Gastroenteritis (AGE) Logs
Violation: The AGE log format was not in the exact order as required by the 2011 VSP Operations Manual (Annex 13.2.2) and there were some additional columns added to the log. All of the correct information was collected for each case in the log.
Recommendation: Ensure the AGE surveillance log entry for each passenger or crew member contain the following information in separate columns: (1) Date of the first medical visit or report to staff of illness; (2) time of the first medical visit or report to staff of illness; (3) case identification number; (4) person's name; (5) person's age; (6) person's sex; (7) designation as passenger or crew member; (8) crew member position or job on the vessel, if applicable; (9) cabin number; (10) meal seating information; (11) date of illness onset; (12) time of illness onset; (13) illness symptoms, including the presence or absence of the following selected signs and symptoms, with a separate column for each of the following: (a) number of episodes of diarrhea in a 24-hour period; (b) number of episodes of vomiting in a 24-hour period; (c) bloody stools; (d) recorded temperature; (e) abdominal cramps; (f) headaches; (g) muscle aches; (14) entry (yes/no) for whether this was a reportable case; (15) entry (yes/no) for antidiarrheal medications sold or dispensed by designated medical staff; (16) presence of underlying medical conditions that may affect interpretation of AGE. Ensure the AGE surveillance log contains the above information in the exact order and is entered in the template in Annex 13.2.2. Ensure that the log data is exported in the exact order as in the example template in Annex 13.2.2 with analyzable formats such as Excel or Access. Ensure that any additional data fields are entered only outside of the form margins when exported to VSP.
Item No.: 36
Site: Food Service General-Lighting
Violation: The light intensity was below 110 lux behind and around many pieces of deck- and counter-mounted equipment. These include the lido beverage stations, lido galley hot section, and the main galley behind the ice machines.
Recommendation: Ensure the light intensity is at least 110 lux (10 foot candles) behind and around mounted equipment, including counter-mounted equipment.
Item No.: 19
Site: Galley-
Violation: Stacks of bowls and plates out for service were not inverted or covered. The area was in use at the time of the inspection. This was corrected.
Recommendation: During service, ensure the food contact portion of each self-service food dispensing utensil is covered or located beneath shielding. Ensure that dishware, glassware, and utensils out for service are inverted or covered.
Item No.: 24
Site: Galley-Port Omelet Preperation Area
Violation: A container of chlorine sanitizing solution with wiping cloths was measured at less than 50 ppm. The area was in use at the time of the inspection. The solution was replaced.
Recommendation: Ensure sanitizing solutions are used with the following concentrations: (1) A chlorine solution with a concentration between 50 mg/L (ppm) and 200 mg/L (ppm).
Item No.: 33
Site: Buffet-Bakery Oven
Violation: The bulkhead to the right of the bakery oven was soiled with dust.
Recommendation: Ensure decks, bulkheads, deckheads, and attached equipment in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are cleaned as often as necessary.
Item No.: 16
Site: Buffet-Omelet Stations
Violation: There was no consumer advisory statement for eggs which could be cooked to order.
Recommendation: If an animal food such as beef, eggs, fish, lamb, milk, pork, poultry, or shellfish that is raw, undercooked, or not otherwise processed to eliminate pathogens is offered in a ready-to-eat form or as a raw ingredient in another ready-to-eat food, ensure the consumer is informed by way of disclosure using menu advisories, placards, or other easily visible written means of the significantly increased risk to certain especially vulnerable consumers eating such foods in raw or undercooked form. Locate the advisory at the outlets where these types of food are served. Ensure that disclosure is made by one of the two following methods: (1) On a sign describing the animal-derived foods (e.g., "oysters on the half-shell," "hamburgers," "steaks," or "eggs"); AND that they can be cooked to order and may be served raw or undercooked; AND a statement indicating that consuming raw or undercooked meats, seafood, shellfish, eggs, milk, poultry may increase your risk for foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Ensure the advisory is posted at the specific station where the food is served raw, undercooked, or cooked to order.
Item No.: 28
Site: Galley-Storage Locker
Violation: In the storage locker across form the ice machine, a few previously cleaned dishes were not inverted to allow for air drying and the shelves below the dishes were wet.
Recommendation: Store clean equipment and utensils in a self-draining position that allows air drying, and covered or inverted.
Item No.: 33
Site: Galley-Hot Section
Violation: The deck tile was missing behind oven #5007 where the water supply line penetrated the deck. Water was pooled on the deck at the missing deck tile. The sealant was loose at the deck around the stainless steel protection cube for ovens #5007 and 5008 water supply line.
Recommendation: Ensure decks, bulkheads, and deckheads in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are maintained in good repair.
Item No.: 37
Site: Galley-Potwash
Violation: Condensation was collecting on the right side of the deckhead above the in-use hood-type potwash machine and on the front of the air conditioning unit above the in-use three-compartment sink. No condensation was observed dripping and no clean items were impacted.
Recommendation: Ensure ventilation hood systems and devices are sufficient in number and capacity to prevent grease or condensation from collecting on bulkheads and deckheads.
Item No.: 20
Site: Preparation Room-
Violation: There was one slotted fastener in the food contact area of the right potato peeler. The area was not in use at the time of the inspection.
Recommendation: Use only low profile, nonslotted, noncorroding, and easy-to-clean fasteners on food-contact surfaces and in splash zones. Prohibit the use of exposed slotted screws, Phillips head screws, or pop rivets in these areas.
Item No.: 39
Site: Preparation Room-
Violation: There was one live fly above the band saw. The area was not in use at the time of the inspection.
Recommendation: Effectively control the presence of insects, rodents, and other pests to minimize their presence in the food storage, preparation, and service areas and warewashing and utensil storage areas aboard a vessel.
Item No.: 39
Site: Galley-Hot Section
Violation: There was one live fly above the tilting kettles. The area was in use at the time of the inspection.
Recommendation: Effectively control the presence of insects, rodents, and other pests to minimize their presence in the food storage, preparation, and service areas and warewashing and utensil storage areas aboard a vessel.
Item No.: 19
Site: Buffet-Crew Mess
Violation: Two containers of bread and five containers of unpackaged crackers were out for service in covered containers at the buffet line and the containers were not equipped with self-closing hinged lids or under a sneeze guard. Staff moved two of the bread containers below the sneeze guard. The buffet was open during the time of the inspection.
Recommendation: Protect food on display from contamination by the use of packaging; counter, service line, or salad bar food guards; display cases; self-closing hinged lids; or other effective means. Install side protection for sneeze guards if the distance between exposed food and where consumers are expected to stand is less than 1 meter (40 inches).
Item No.: 19
Site: Buffet-Crew and Officer Messes
Violation: Stacks of plates out for service were not inverted or covered. These areas were in use at the time of the inspection. This was corrected.
Recommendation: During service, ensure the food contact portion of each self-service food dispensing utensil is covered or located beneath shielding. Ensure that dishware, glassware, and utensils out for service are inverted or covered.
Item No.: 21
Site: Buffet-Crew Mess
Violation: The lower right corner of the sneeze guard to the left of the plate stand was chipped.
Recommendation: Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment that are exposed to splash, spillage, or other food soiling or that require frequent cleaning are constructed of a corrosion-resistant, nonabsorbent, and smooth material.
Item No.: 19
Site: Bar-Trident Bar
Violation: A covered container of cookies was out for service at the passenger bar counter and was not equipped with a self-closing hinged lid or under a sneeze guard. The bar was open during the time of the inspection.
Recommendation: Protect food on display from contamination by the use of packaging; counter, service line, or salad bar food guards; display cases; self-closing hinged lids; or other effective means. Install side protection for sneeze guards if the distance between exposed food and where consumers are expected to stand is less than 1 meter (40 inches).
Item No.: 33
Site: Bar-Trident Bar
Violation: The deckhead above the food preparation areas was constructed of metal in an open grid-like pattern that exposed the ventilation piping, rusted metal components, and coils. This deckhead is scheduled to be replaced during the Spring 2012 dry dock.
Recommendation: Ensure decks, bulkheads, and deckheads in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, bars, and food and equipment storage areas are constructed and maintained for easy cleaning. Do not use carpet in these areas.
*Inspections scores of 85 or lower are NOT satisfactory
Vessel Sanitation Program